Ice Cream · 48oz / 1.5 QT
Lake Erie Cookie Island Monster
Cookies. Blue Swirl. Pure Fun. Toft's Lake Erie Cookie Monster™ is a tribute to Ohio's great lake and to the unsinkable joy of blue frosting. A smooth vanilla ice cream base — made with fresh Ohio dairy — is swirled with bright blue frosting ribbon and loaded with chocolate cookie pieces that bring crunch, richness, and pure cookie joy to every scoop. This is playful ice cream for people who don't believe dessert has to be serious.
- No artificial growth hormones (rBST-free milk from all partner farms)
- Gluten Free
- Kosher Certified
- Allergen Alert: Contains Milk, Wheat & Soy
Full ingredients & nutrition from Toft clean-label 2026 product documents · code 738.
Available Sizes
The full story
Lake Erie Cookie Monster™: Ohio Pride in a Scoop
The color of Lake Erie at its most brilliant — that clear, bright blue on a perfect summer day — inspired this flavor. The blue frosting swirl captures that exact shade while delivering the sweet, creamy taste that makes frosting the best part of the cake. But this isn't just color and sweetness. The chocolate cookie pieces ensure every scoop has texture, richness, and that deeply satisfying cookie flavor.
Lake Erie Cookie Monster™ is the flavor for families. For the person who never grew up and still loves a blue-frosting-swirled birthday cake experience. For everyone who believes ice cream should be as fun as it is delicious. The base is, of course, fresh Ohio cream — the same quality dairy that defines all Toft's products. That quality foundation ensures even our most playful flavors have the richness and creaminess to stand up to their more traditional counterparts.
The chocolate cookie pieces are generous and well-distributed, ensuring variety in every serving. Some scoops bring you more frosting-swirl forward, others balance cookie and blue frosting and vanilla in equal measure. That unpredictability is part of the fun.
A perennial favorite at family gatherings, birthday parties, and in the freezers of people who take their blue frosting seriously.
