Ice cream · Hand-churned since 1900
Real ice cream. Real milk. Real family.
Hand-churned in Sandusky from rBST-free milk on family farms within 50 miles of our creamery. Tilly Tracks®, clean-label classics, sherbets, and limited editions — dense, creamy texture without industrial shortcuts. Every flavor page tells the full story.
Signature line
Meet Tilly Tracks®
Chocolate cows, thick fudge, and ice cream that earns the seal. Start with Salty Caramel or Chocolate — then find your favorite track.
Tilly Tracks®
The herd favorite — fudge, mix-ins, and chocolate cows.
Classics & favorites
Everyday scoops worth stocking the freezer for.
48oz / 1.5 QT
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Brown Butter Bourbon Truffle
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Brownie Bandit
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Butter Pecan
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Caveman Chocolate
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Cheesecake Cookie Faceoff
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Chocolate
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Cold Brew Caramel Latte
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Cookies 'n Cream
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Feelin' Dangerous
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
French Vanilla
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Muddy's Sea Salt Slam
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Neapolitan
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Peanut Butter 'n Cookies
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Peanut Butter Cup
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Vanilla
View product →
48oz / 1.5 QT
Vanilla Bean
View product →Sherbet
Bright, refreshing, and built for warm Ohio days.
Seasonal & limited
Catch them while they last.
